8 Phrases That Instantly Turn Small Talk into a Real Conversation
Stop Talking About the Weather—Say This Instead
So here’s the thing, Small talk is like stale popcorn—fine if you’re starving, but mostly just a waste of chewing.
And yet, people do it all the time. Like clockwork.
Nod. Smile. “Crazy weather, huh?” “Mondays, am I right?” “What do you do for work?”
That’s it. That’s the whole interaction.
The problem isn’t that people don’t want to talk about real stuff. It’s just that nobody knows how to get there without sounding weird or like they’re trying too hard.
So, what do you do? You throw them a sentence they can’t respond to with autopilot nonsense. You shake the Etch A Sketch in their brain and make them actually think before they speak.
Here are eight phrases that do exactly that.
1. “You don’t really think that, do you?”
People say things just to fill the silence. Little pre-packaged lines they’ve repeated so many times they don’t even hear them anymore.
This knocks them off script.
🔸 Going with the usual = Background noise.
🔸 Calling it out = Instant spark.
Example:
Them: “Ugh, everyone’s so sensitive these days.”
You: “You don’t actually think that, do you?”
Them: “Well, I mean… I guess some things are just people asking for basic respect.”
You: “Exactly. Nobody was calling it ‘being too sensitive’ when people used to smoke indoors and nobody questioned it.”
What happens here? Instead of nodding along, they’re actually processing what they just said. They’re thinking. And thinking means the conversation has started.
2. “What’s something you were totally wrong about?”
People like to pretend they’ve always had it figured out. They haven’t. Nobody has.
This makes them reflect. And reflecting makes them interesting.
🔸 Refusing to admit you were wrong = Boring.
🔸 Owning your past mistakes = Engaging.
Example:
Them: “I used to think working out was just for meatheads.”
You: “What changed?”
Them: “Oh, just, you know… realizing I actually feel less like garbage when I move my body sometimes.”
See? Simple. No forced deep talk. Just a window into how they actually see things now versus how they used to.
3. “What’s a strong opinion you have that usually gets side-eyes?”
Most people filter themselves down to the safest, most vanilla version of their thoughts.
This opens the cage and lets the real takes fly.
🔸 Saying what’s expected = Forgettable.
🔸 Dropping a take people don’t expect = Worth talking about.
Example:
Them: “I think tipping culture is out of control.”
You: “Oh yeah? What makes you say that?”
Them: “I just think, like, if a business can’t afford to pay their employees, that’s their problem, not mine.”
Now you’re not just swapping generic lines. You’re into why people believe what they believe.
4. “What’s something you pretend to enjoy but secretly can’t stand?”
Everybody fakes enthusiasm for something. Nobody wants to be the one person in the group who says, “Actually? I hate sushi.”
Give them permission to confess.
🔸 Pretending to be excited = Exhausting.
🔸 Laughing about fake excitement = Instant connection.
Example:
Them: “I act like I love hiking, but honestly? It’s just walking. For hours. And then walking back.”
You: “Oh my God, finally someone said it.”
This works because you know they’ve been holding it in. And once one confession comes out, more tend to follow.
5. “What’s a job most people assume is easy but is actually hell?”
Nobody likes when their work gets dismissed as “easy.” This lets them rant in a way that’s actually interesting.
🔸 “What do you do for work?” = Dry.
🔸 “What’s a job people underestimate?” = Something to talk about.
Example:
Them: “Barista. People think it’s just pouring coffee, but have you ever tried making a latte with a line of 12 angry customers breathing down your neck?”
You: “Not to mention remembering 40 different milk alternatives.”
Them: “EXACTLY. I had a woman ask me for ‘a splash’ of oat milk and then accuse me of putting too much oat in her oat milk latte.”
Now they’re actually engaged in the conversation.
6. “What’s something people assume about you that’s completely wrong?”
People don’t just like this question. They love it.
Because it’s a chance to clear up all the nonsense people think about them.
🔸 Being misunderstood = Frustrating.
🔸 Setting the record straight = Strangely satisfying.
Example:
Them: “People think I’m super organized. I am not. I’m just really good at hiding my mess.”
You: “You mean you have a ‘clean room’ and then a ‘throw-everything-in-there’ room?”
Them: “EXACTLY.”
It works because everyone has that one thing people assume that is just… dead wrong.
7. “What’s a belief you had five years ago that now makes you cringe?”
Nobody stays the same forever. This makes them show their growth in a way that doesn’t feel forced.
🔸 Acting like you’ve always been wise = Fake.
🔸 Owning past dumb beliefs = Relatable.
Example:
Them: “I used to think I could just ‘manifest’ money into existence.”
You: “Oh no. Were you making a vision board?”
Them: “You don’t even know. I had pictures of yachts on my fridge.”
Nothing connects people faster than admitting to being a little bit of an idiot in the past.
8. “What’s a weird fact you learned recently that blew your mind?”
Most people forget 90% of what they see and hear. But every once in a while, something sticks.
This question lets them share that one ridiculous fact that’s been haunting them.
🔸 Normal facts = Meh.
🔸 “Wait, WHAT?” facts = Fun.
Example:
Them: “Did you know octopuses have three hearts?”
You: “Wait… what happens if they have a heart attack?”
Them: “I don’t know, and now I need to Google it.”
Wait a Sec
If you want to read more stories like this,
Join Curious People like you in my newsletter:
Your time means a lot to me, and I promise not to waste it.
Thank you!